Anthony A. Nozzolillo, Esq.Attorney at Law · Merrick, New York

Do I Need a Lawyer to Buy a House in New York?

It is asked of me several times a month, usually by somebody who has already found the house and has begun to suspect that the process ahead of them has more moving parts than they were led to believe. The question is a fair one and it deserves a direct answer.

No statute of this State compels a Purchaser or a Seller of residential real property to retain an attorney. A person is free to proceed without one.

That answer, standing alone, misleads almost everybody who hears it, and the reason is worth setting out.

What the Law Actually Prohibits:

New York does not compel you to hire an attorney. What it does is forbid nearly everyone else involved in your transaction from doing the work an attorney would do.

Judiciary Law §484 provides that no natural person shall ask or receive, directly or indirectly, compensation for preparing "deeds, mortgages, assignments, discharges, leases or any other instruments affecting real estate," unless that person has been regularly admitted to practice. Judiciary Law §495(3) imposes the identical prohibition upon corporations and voluntary associations, in the same words.

The prohibition is framed around compensation, and the penalty is real. A violation is a misdemeanor under Judiciary Law §485, and under §485-a it becomes a class E felony where the person falsely holds himself out as licensed to practice and causes another to suffer monetary loss exceeding one thousand dollars ($1,000.00) or other material damage resulting from impairment of a legal right.

So the question is not whether the law requires you to have a lawyer. It is who, at a closing table full of licensed professionals, is permitted to answer a legal question when one arises.

Why the Broker Who Hands You the Contract Is Not Breaking It:

A reasonable person reads the foregoing and wonders how a real estate broker may hand a Purchaser a Contract of Sale at all.

The answer is a narrow and conditional privilege, and both of the State agencies concerned have described its limits. The Attorney General addressed the question directly in Formal Opinion No. 96-F11, issued 14 November 1996, concluding that brokers are not engaged in the unauthorized practice of law where they prepare purchase and sale contracts which expressly state that the documents are subject to review by the parties' attorneys, or where they use forms approved by the appropriate organizations and insert nothing requiring legal expertise. The Opinion adds a sentence which deserves more attention than it receives: "This limited privilege must be narrowly circumscribed."

The Department of State sets out the same limits in its Legal Memorandum LI04. A broker may fill in non-legal provisions — the names of the parties, the date and location of the closing, a description of the property, the consideration for sale. A broker "would not be permitted to develop any 'legal terms'," must "refrain from inserting in a real estate purchase offer or counteroffer any provision which requires the exercise of legal expertise," and may not undertake to devise the detailed terms of a purchase money mortgage. A broker may not provide legal advice to his clients, may not charge a separate fee for preparing the Contract, and may not discourage the parties from seeking advice from their attorneys, which is the provision I would underline for any Purchaser reading this.

The seminal case is Duncan & Hill Realty, Inc. v. Department of State, 62 A.D.2d 690 (4th Dept. 1978), in which a broker's conduct in this territory was found to constitute untrustworthiness and incompetence under Real Property Law §441-c. The Department of State continues to apply its standards, and a broker who crosses the line risks suspension or revocation of the license he earns his living with.

The Clause in Your Contract Exists Because of All This:

Look at the Contract of Sale you have been handed and you will very likely find a provision making it subject to approval by the attorneys for the Seller and the Purchaser within a stated number of days.

Most Purchasers take that clause for a formality. The Court of Appeals has explained what it is actually for. In Moran v Erk, 11 N.Y.3d 452 (2008), the Court observed that the attorney approval contingency "ensures that real estate brokers avoid the unauthorized practice of law" and "allows both contracting parties to have agents representing their respective legal interests."

Read that in light of §484 and the structure becomes plain. The clause is in your Contract because the person who prepared that Contract is forbidden to practice law, and the clause is what keeps the arrangement lawful. The document presumes an attorney will read it. That is the sense in which New York is called an attorney State — a description of a mechanism rather than a statute.

The Court went further, and the holding is worth a Purchaser's attention. Where the Contract makes itself subject to or contingent upon attorney approval within a specified period and sets no further limitation, an attorney for either party "may timely disapprove the contract for any reason or for no stated reason." No vested rights are created before that period expires. A Purchaser with counsel during those few days holds a position he will never hold again in the transaction, and most spend that period waiting for a telephone call.

The Title Company Is Not Your Attorney Either:

There is one carve-out in this area, and it is narrower than people assume.

Judiciary Law §495(5) provides that the section does not apply to a corporation or voluntary association lawfully engaged in the examination and insuring of titles to real property, as to instruments affecting real property insofar as they are necessary to the examination and insuring of titles, and those necessary or incidental to that company's own loans. The same subdivision then sets a ceiling upon the exception: no such corporation "shall be permitted to render any services which cannot lawfully be rendered by a person not admitted to practice law in this state."

I have served for a number of years as Chief Legal Counsel to a title insurance company and as General Counsel to a loan settlement company, so I will put it plainly. A title company examines the record and insures what it finds. It does not represent you, it owes you no duty to tell you what an exception on Schedule B means for the house you are buying, and the statute which permits it to operate at all expressly forbids it from rendering services a non-lawyer could not render.

What Actually Goes Wrong:

It is one thing to be told that an attorney is advisable. Here is what I have seen from the other side of the file.

A Contract is executed. A mortgage commitment issues. The Title Report comes back carrying a Satisfaction of Mortgage that was never recorded, or a Judgment docketed against a stranger who shares the Seller's surname, or a mechanic's lien from a renovation three winters ago, or an Estate left open in the chain of title. Each of those is ordinary. Each is discoverable. Each takes longer to clear than the Contract allows once the clock has started.

What determines whether the Closing survives is whether somebody at the table owns the problem. The broker is forbidden to advise upon it. The title company has done its job by disclosing it. The lender will decline to fund until it is resolved and has no interest in how. Where no attorney was retained, the exception sits in the file and the Closing date passes, and the first a Purchaser hears of any of it is a telephone call explaining that the matter is adjourned.

In Summation:

No statute requires you to hire an attorney to buy a house in New York. The law instead forbids your broker from giving you legal advice, forbids the title company from rendering services only a lawyer may render, and places in your Contract a clause whose stated purpose, in the words of the Court of Appeals, is to allow both parties to have agents representing their legal interests.

A Purchaser who proceeds without counsel has broken no rule. He has simply arranged matters so that at the moment a legal question arises — and in a residential transaction one almost always does — there is nobody present whom the law permits to answer it.

Be sure to consult a seasoned attorney before executing a Contract of Sale, and well before the attorney approval period has run.

DISCLAIMER: THIS ARTICLE IS FOR INFORMATIONAL PURPOSES ONLY AND IS NOT TO BE RELIED UPON AS LEGAL ADVICE. NO ATTORNEY CLIENT RELATIONSHIP IS CREATED BY THIS PUBLICATION. AN INDEPENDENT LEGAL OPINION SHOULD BE OBTAINED BY THE READER.

All articles

Is there a Contract of Sale in front of you?

An attorney approval period runs only a few days, and it is the stretch of a purchase in which counsel can do the most. Ask the question—there is no obligation.