Anthony A. Nozzolillo, Esq.Attorney at Law · Merrick, New York

My Sibling Sold His Share of Our Inherited House to an Investor

It is put to me in different words each time and the facts are nearly always the same. A parent died some years ago and left a house to two or three children. One of those children has now sold his share to a company nobody in the family had heard of, and the first anyone learned of it was a letter, a telephone call, or a notice taped to the door.

The question that follows is whether the family has lost the house.

The answer turns on a date, and the date is July 19, 2024.

What the Purchaser Bought, and What He Could Once Do With It:

A share in a house held as tenants in common belongs to the co-tenant who owns it, and he may sell it. He requires no permission from his siblings and at common law he owes them no notice. What the purchaser acquires is an undivided fractional interest in the whole, together with the remedy that has always accompanied such an interest.

That remedy is partition. RPAPL §901 permits a tenant in common in possession under an estate of inheritance to maintain an action for partition, and for a sale where partition "cannot be made without great prejudice to the owners." A purchaser holding a one-quarter (1/4) share stands in the place of the co-tenant who sold it to him and may bring that action.

This is a business and it operates on a simple arithmetic. A company buys a minority share at a steep discount from its proportionate value, commences a partition action, and the house is sold. The family's position is to fund a buyout at a figure the company has a hand in setting, or to watch the property go.

What the Legislature Did in 2019:

New York adopted the Uniform Partition of Heirs Property Act in 2019 as RPAPL §993. Where a property qualifies as heirs property, a partition action proceeds under a sequence of procedures built to keep the house with the family.

There is a mandatory settlement conference, held "within sixty days after the date when a request for judicial intervention is filed." There is an appraisal by a disinterested appraiser licensed in this State, valuing the fee as though it were solely owned. The remaining co-tenants hold a right to buy out the interest of the co-tenant seeking partition at that determined value. Partition in kind is the preference, and the court "shall order partition in kind" unless division would result in "great manifest prejudice to the co-tenants as a group." Where a sale is nonetheless ordered, it proceeds as an open-market sale through a licensed broker rather than at auction.

Those are substantial protections and they have changed outcomes. The purchaser, however, retained his seat in court. A company that had bought a share could still file, and the family still had to fund a buyout or submit to a sale.

What Changed on July 19, 2024:

Chapter 56 of the Laws of 2024, signed on April 20, 2024, carried at its Part O the heirs property protection and deed theft prevention act of 2024. That Part took effect on the ninetieth (90th) day thereafter, July 19, 2024, and it added two subdivisions to §993.

Subdivision 12 is headed "Prohibition on initiation of a partition action." It provides that no partition action related to an heirs property may be initiated by a party that purchased or otherwise acquired its share or shares "by means other than inheritance."

That is the bar the 2019 Act did without. A company which buys a minority share in heirs property now lacks the standing to commence the action at all.

Subdivision 13 is headed "Right of first refusal," and it reaches the sale itself rather than the lawsuit which may follow. Where a co-tenant receives a bona fide offer from a person who is not already a co-tenant, the co-tenants who inherited their shares, and relatives of those who did, may purchase upon "the identical price, terms, and conditions" of that offer. A co-tenant occupying the property as a primary residence takes first priority; one who otherwise uses the property takes second.

The notice obligation is where these matters are won and lost. Both the offeror and the co-tenant who receives the offer must use due diligence to identify and notify the other co-tenants, with service made as provided in CPLR §308. Those co-tenants then have "one hundred eighty days from the date they are notified of the offer to match such offer."

Where the sale has already closed without that notice having been given, the remaining co-tenants may purchase the shares from the buyer at the price he paid, "plus any applicable interest at a rate of two percent per annum." That right expires one hundred eighty (180) days after the other co-tenants are made aware of the sale.

Read the two subdivisions together and the arithmetic of the business comes apart. A company that bought a share for a fraction of its proportionate value is barred from filing for partition, and may be compelled to convey the share back at what it paid plus two percent (2%).

Why the Date on the Deed Decides What You Have:

Part O took effect on July 19, 2024, and it says nothing at all about whether subdivisions 12 and 13 reach what occurred before that day. That silence governs a great deal.

Where the sale closed on or after July 19, 2024, the notice obligations were in force at the closing. If the family was never notified, the buy-back right in subdivision 13 is available, and its one hundred eighty (180) days runs from the date the family became aware of the sale rather than from the closing itself.

Where the sale closed before July 19, 2024, no notice obligation existed at the time, and the buy-back remedy has nothing to attach itself to.

The difficult question lies between the two: a share bought before July 19, 2024, with the partition action commenced after it. Does subdivision 12 bar that filing?

No court has yet answered. In Majewski v. Broadalbin-Perth Central School District, 91 N.Y.2d 577 (1998), the Court of Appeals stated the governing rule in a single line: "That a statute is to be applied prospectively is strongly presumed." Retroactive operation "is not favored by courts and statutes will not be given such construction unless the language expressly or by necessary implication requires it."

Two features of the 2024 Act bear upon the question and both point in the same direction. When the Legislature amended this same section in 2022, it provided expressly that the amendment "shall apply to actions and proceedings pending on and after such effective date." Part O carries no such provision for subdivisions 12 or 13. And Part O does carry an applicability rule in the very same final section, governing the transfer on death deed provisions enacted alongside, which reach a deed made "before, on, or after the effective date of this act" where the transferor dies on or after it. The Legislature knew how to write such a rule, wrote one for a neighboring provision, and wrote none for the partition bar.

Majewski turned upon that same species of silence. An earlier draft of the statute there at issue "expressly provided" that it would reach pending suits, and "[t]hat language does not appear in the enacted version," which the Court found "consistent with the strong presumption of prospective application in the absence of a clear statement concerning retroactivity."

Nor does the protective purpose of the heirs property legislation carry the point by itself. The Court of Appeals has held that classifying a statute as "remedial" "does not automatically overcome the strong presumption of prospectivity."

A purchaser whose money went out before July 19, 2024 will argue that the bar cannot be applied against him without stripping away a remedy which accompanied the share when he acquired it. A family will argue that subdivision 12 governs the act of commencing an action, that the act of commencement occurs when the papers are filed, and that a filing made after the effective date is governed by the statute then in force. Both arguments are serious ones. The question is open and a court will decide it.

A Bronx Case Worth Knowing About:

In Gelinas LLC v Hayes, 2024 NY Slip Op 24273, 85 Misc 3d 1012 (Sup Ct, Bronx County 2024), the Supreme Court applied the 2019 Act to a partition action which a development company had very nearly carried to its conclusion.

The company purchased a nephew's twenty-five percent (25%) share of a Bronx residence for fifteen thousand dollars ($15,000.00) in May of 2020 and commenced its partition action in January of 2021, holding that quarter interest alone. In May of 2021 it acquired a niece's share for sixty thousand dollars ($60,000.00). The court would later describe "[t]he low price paid by Gelinas ($75,000)." A Judgment of Partition and Sale was entered on January 27, 2023.

The woman who had lived in the house for years moved under §993. The court held that the residence qualified as heirs property "because the niece was an heir at the time of the commencement of the partition action," observing that the categorization "is determined on the date of the filing of the partition petition." It vacated the Judgment of Partition and Sale, directed the Clerk to mark it vacated in all court records, and sent the matter forward to a partition of heirs property settlement conference.

Two points carry well beyond that case. Heirs property status is fixed as of the date of filing, so a purchaser gains nothing by buying out the inheriting co-tenants after he has sued. And a Judgment of Partition and Sale is not the end of the matter where the Act was never applied to begin with.

The court also took notice of the 2024 amendments, which it described as "[a]lthough not applicable to this proceeding," and said of them that "a purchaser such as Gelinas lacks standing to even commence a partition proceeding" where "the property was owned by an heir, and Gelinas acquired its shares ‘by means other than inheritance.’" That observation is dictum in a case the court had already determined the amendments did not govern, and the court offered no reason for their inapplicability. It is nonetheless the first judicial reading of subdivision 12, and it reads the subdivision as the Legislature wrote it.

What to Do, and When:

Obtain the deed. The conveyance from your co-tenant to the purchaser is a recorded instrument, and it carries both the date of the closing and the consideration paid. That date determines which of the rights set out above exist, and that consideration is the figure against which a buy-back under subdivision 13 would be measured.

Fix the date upon which you learned of the sale. Both of subdivision 13's one hundred eighty (180) day periods run from notification or from awareness rather than from the closing. A period which has begun to run grows shorter every week it is left alone.

Take no step which reads as a request for a sale. Under the 2019 Act, a co-tenant who requests a sale thereby consents that his own interest may be purchased. Where the object is to keep the house, the record ought to show that object from the beginning.

Where a partition action has already been commenced, say so to counsel at once. The mandatory settlement conference arrives within sixty (60) days of the request for judicial intervention, and the appraisal, objection and election periods which follow it are measured in days. A co-tenant who appears late in that sequence holds fewer options than one who appears at its start.

In Summation:

A co-tenant may sell his share of an inherited house and he need not ask the rest of the family first. What a purchaser may do with that share changed on July 19, 2024. He may no longer commence a partition action over heirs property, and where he bought without the notice the statute requires, the family may purchase the share back at what he paid plus two percent (2%) per annum.

Whether those provisions reach a purchase made before that date where the lawsuit comes after it has yet to be decided, and the presumption that a statute operates prospectively is a strong one.

The date on the deed is therefore the first thing to establish and the date you learned of the sale is the second. Each of them starts a clock.

Be sure to consult a seasoned attorney upon learning that a share of a family property has been sold, and well before any of those one hundred eighty (180) day periods has run.

DISCLAIMER: THIS ARTICLE IS FOR INFORMATIONAL PURPOSES ONLY AND IS NOT TO BE RELIED UPON AS LEGAL ADVICE. NO ATTORNEY CLIENT RELATIONSHIP IS CREATED BY THIS PUBLICATION. AN INDEPENDENT LEGAL OPINION SHOULD BE OBTAINED BY THE READER.

All articles

Has a share of your family's house been sold to a company?

The date on the deed decides which rights the family holds, and the time to act on them may already be running. Ask the question—there is no obligation.